Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt Recipe (2024)

Food

Posted on March 25, 2018March 17, 2022 by Brittany Bly

25
Mar

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Mmmmmmmmmmm yum! And did I also mention mmmmm? Because this Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt recipe is to die for! It’s so delicious, creamy, with just a hint of that awesome froyo tartness that I love.

This recipe didn’t exist anywhere online which I thought was just crazy! So I had to make this up myself and adapt it from cookies and cream ice cream and this froyo recipe that I made up myself here.

It’s a lot healthier than ice cream and issuper easy to make. It does have a couple of quirks so reading these directions is super important. Usually I would say skip to the end and just print out the recipe but this Cookies and Cream Frozen Yogurt Recipe actually has a few quirks.

First of all, make sure your cream cheese is warmed to room temperature before you add it to the yogurt. You absolutely must blend your cream cheese thoroughly into your yogurt before you add it to the ice cream maker. I used a Kitchen-Aid mixer for about 5 minutes to blend my ingredients.

If you don’t blend your cream cheese thoroughly, you will end up with chunks of cream cheese inside the frozen yogurt which is even more unappealing than it sounds!

This was the most problematic part in following other’s directions because no one mentioned to warm the cream cheese and then blend it thoroughly.

It’s also important to add less sugar than you would for a normal frozen yogurt recipe. Because you are adding oreo cookies which are pretty sweet, the overall recipe requires less sugar!

It’s not necessary but if you blend your sugar in early, the flavor will be more consistent because the sugar breaks down faster.

The last important thing that you need to know about this recipe is that if you want chunky bits of cookie, be sure to mix in the cookies right before you are done blending all your ingredients together.

If you want a smooth even cookie texture, you can mix your oreo cookies when you add the yogurt & cream cheese mixture.

I chose chunky cookie bits because I love a bit of crunch! Now scroll down to get the full printable recipe and enjoy your delicious Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt!

Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt Recipe (6)

Brittany Bly

This Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt Recipe is a healthier lighter way to get your cookie fix! It has just a hint of tartness that you need out of frozen yogurt. Enjoy!

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 45 minutes mins

Course Dessert

Ingredients

  • 2 cups Plain Full Fat Yogurt
  • 4 oz. Cream Cheese
  • 1/3 cup White Sugar
  • 1 heaped tablespoon Vanilla Bean Paste
  • 12 Oreo Cookies

Instructions

  • Allow your cream cheese to warm to room temperature.

  • Mix together your yogurt, vanilla bean paste, and sugar.

  • Once your cream cheese is at room temperature, blend it together with the yogurt mixture using a Kitchen-Aid or electric mixer. Mix until thoroughly blended - several minutes. Scrap the sides of the bowl several times.

  • Add your ingredients to an ice cream maker and churn for 30 minutes.

  • No ice cream maker? No problem! Just add you mixture to a large plastic tupperware and place in the freezer. Remove from the freezer every 45 minutes and mix thoroughly until frozen (approximately 2-3 hours).

  • Break your Oreo cookies until large chunks and add them to the nearly frozen mixture.

  • Serve immediately.

Keyword Frozen Yogurt Recipe, Healthy Ice Cream Alternative, Pop Shop America Recipes, Sweet Cookies and Cream Treat

Let’s Stay Friends!

Insta | Pinterest | Enews | TikTok

Looking for something similar?

  • Plain Tart Froyo Recipe - Frozen Yogurt

    If there's one thing I love it's Froyo! Going to the frozen yogurt place and…

  • Spicy Gingersnap Cookies Recipe

    Oh I sure to love Gingersnaps! I would say it's one of my favorite cookies.…

  • Like Magic: Make Ice Cream with Dry Ice!

    Interested in ice cream with a pop, bang, fizz? Make Ice Cream with Dry Ice!…

Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt Recipe (13)

Brittany Bly

Hi. My name is Brittany and I'm the founder of Pop Shop America. I design most of the craft kits in our shop and just love to make stuff! I've been a maker my whole life and have made desserts, clothes, terrariums, zines, fine art, recipes, candles and so much more. I hope you stick around at Pop Shop America. 💖 Let's be friends.

Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt Recipe (2024)

FAQs

Can you just freeze yogurt to make frozen yogurt? ›

It's best to keep in mind that the main purpose of freezing yogurt is so you can save it for later use. This process is entirely different from making the frozen yogurt dessert fro-yo, which is essentially yogurt with the texture of ice cream. Hence, you can't just freeze yogurt to make the frozen yogurt dessert.

Why is my homemade frozen yogurt icy? ›

The problem is that yogurt, while creamy when you spoon it from the carton, actually contains a good amount of water and not a lot of fat. When you freeze it, the water forms crystals that make fro-yo icy and decidedly non-creamy.

How do you make frozen yogurt not hard? ›

To make a frozen yogurt you can scoop like ice cream, you need to add sugar. As with ice cream and sorbet, the more sugar you add, the softer your yogurt will be. Sugar molecules get in the way of growing ice crystals, keeping your frozen dessert smooth and creamy.

How many calories is cookies and cream frozen yogurt? ›

Pinkberry
Nutrition Facts
For a Serving Size of 1 mini (90.72g)
How many calories are in Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt? Amount of calories in Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt: Calories 126Calories from Fat 16.2 (12.9%)
% Daily Value *
13 more rows

How long does yogurt need to be in the freezer to freeze? ›

Yogurt takes a few hours to freeze completely. We usually keep it in the freezer overnight to prevent a mess. Step 3: Remove the ice cube trays from the freezer and release the yogurt cubes from the ice cube trays. Step 4: Transfer the cubes to a freezer-friendly ziplock bag or an airtight freezer-friendly container.

How long does frozen yogurt take to freeze? ›

Taste, and if you like it sweeter add a bit more honey. Transfer the mixture to a freezer safe container and smooth the surface. Press a piece of parchment against the top of the yogurt to prevent ice crystals from forming. Freeze for at least 6 hours or overnight.

Will yogurt freeze like ice cream? ›

Yes, you can freeze yogurt to eat like ice cream. Note that the texture may be firmer compared to store-bought frozen yogurt or ice cream, but it still makes a refreshing and healthy snack. How long does yogurt last if I freeze it? Yogurt lasts for one to two months in the freezer.

Can you freeze yogurt like a popsicle? ›

Tips for making the best frozen yogurt popsicles

The full fat in the yogurt helps reduce the water content, so they become more creamy and less icy. Use small paper cups. If you don't have a popsicle mold, you can also use small paper cups. Fill ¾ full, then cover with tin foil.

Is frozen yogurt healthier than ice cream? ›

In this comparison, frozen yogurt ranks as the overall healthiest dessert. One serving of froyo has less than one-fifth as many calories as the same amount of ice cream, making it a good choice if you are trying to lose or maintain weight.

What makes frozen yogurt unhealthy? ›

The frozen stuff also typically includes sugar, flavorings, stabilizers, and cream. Frozen yogurt makers often claim it is a healthier alternative to ice cream, but that depends on the ingredients. It's usually lower in fat and calories than ice cream, but it can be just as high in sugar.

What is the overrun of frozen yogurt? ›

The term overrun refers to the incorporation of air into your product, which allows you to transform your frozen mix into the smooth soft serve your customers know and love. This air gives your soft serve its trademark texture and flavor.

How do you stabilize frozen yogurt? ›

Now to prevent your froyo from crystallizing, you can make golden syrup. All you need to do is boil some water, add sugar and lemon wedge to caramelize the sugar and let it sit for 45 minutes. Golden syrup is just one of the substitute sugars that you could use in making your froyo.

Is frozen yogurt more unhealthy than ice cream? ›

Average all brand of a cup of frozen yogurt contains 10% fat, 37.3 g of sugar, and 221 calories whereas average all brand of a cup of vanilla ice-cream contains 22% fat, 28 g of sugar, and 273 calories. Toppings or the type of ice cream or frozen yogurt may actually determine the healthier choice. Be cautious though!

Does frozen yogurt have more carbs than ice cream? ›

While they're related, they have some differences. Depending on the brand, frozen yogurt often has fewer calories than most ice cream brands. Many recognize frozen yogurt has less fat than regular ice cream and may choose “froyo” instead. As for protein and carbohydrates, the icy duo has similar amounts.

How many carbs are in frozen yogurt cookies and cream? ›

Smart Snack: Cookies 'n' Cream
Total Fat 1.5g2%
Total Carbohydrates 24g9%
Dietary Fiber 0g0%
Total Sugar 18g
Includes 13g Added Sugars26%
9 more rows

Can you freeze yogurt and eat it like ice cream? ›

Yes, you can freeze yogurt to eat like ice cream. Note that the texture may be firmer compared to store-bought frozen yogurt or ice cream, but it still makes a refreshing and healthy snack. How long does yogurt last if I freeze it? Yogurt lasts for one to two months in the freezer.

Can you freeze yogurt and then unfreeze it? ›

Fresh yoghurt freezes remarkably well for up to two months. Upon thawing, the texture may change slightly and appear to be more liquid or grainy than it originally was. A simple fix is to stir vigorously for 30 seconds before using to even out the texture.

Why does yogurt say do not freeze? ›

There are several reasons for this recommendation. Firstly, freezing can cause the water in the yogurt to separate from the gel, resulting in a loss of texture. This can make the yogurt become grainy and watery once thawed.

What happens if you freeze Greek yogurt? ›

In comparison to some dairy products that grainy after freezing (like sour cream or cottage cheese), Greek yogurt freezes beautifully. While it may appear to separate after thawing, simply stir it and it returns to its original texture. It works to eat fresh, or to use in cooked or baked recipes.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Domingo Moore

Last Updated:

Views: 6408

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Domingo Moore

Birthday: 1997-05-20

Address: 6485 Kohler Route, Antonioton, VT 77375-0299

Phone: +3213869077934

Job: Sales Analyst

Hobby: Kayaking, Roller skating, Cabaret, Rugby, Homebrewing, Creative writing, amateur radio

Introduction: My name is Domingo Moore, I am a attractive, gorgeous, funny, jolly, spotless, nice, fantastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.